Book Review-Newsman: Tracking India in The Modi Era

Book: Newsman: Tracking India in The Modi Era

Author: Rajdeep Sardesai

Pages: 234

Publisher: Rupa Publications

Genre: Non-fiction

Rating: 3

Price: 500

The General Elections of 2014 in India saw the rise of a prime minister, who is, perhaps, only overshadowed by Indira Gandhi. Four years since the Modi regime, the country has witnessed events that shook the nation like no other- demonetisation, implementation of GST, cow protection laws and what not. From cow-vigilantism taking lives to protests in support of rapists, mob attacks on movies, terming every citizen questioning the govt. as ‘anti-national’, and the Hindutva brigades striving for a Hindu nation, intolerance in the country is at its peak. Newsman is a collection of articles written by Rajdeep Sardesai over these past four years in light of the above events/issues and more.


The book is divided into five sections, each constituting Sardesai’s articles analysing distinct aspects of the Modi govt. For example, while one section talks about today’s hot topic-nationalism and the drive to convert India into a Hindu Rashtra, another one talks about the ‘challenges before a ‘new’ India’ and the various scandals associated with the govt. Each article is followed by the author’s comment on its relevance now, highlighting what has/ has not changed. Throughout the book, we also get a glimpse into the life of Sardesai, not only as a journalist but as a father, a man who enjoys all festivals with equal fervour and who wears the tag of an anti-nationalist proudly around his neck. He ends the book on a ‘prayer for his country’, which coming from Sardesai was sub-standard and the content of the prayer, I feel, is quite far-fetched. (“Where a woman feels safe on the streets at midnight and can share public spaces with men without being sexually harassed“-seriously? )

The book in a way justified its title– it sheds a light on Sardesai’s life on being ‘the newsman’ at a time when the country is going through turmoils. All his articles are well-written, thoroughly engaging, and gives a commendable critique of the Modi govt. But the ‘Tracking India in the Modi Era’ would have made more sense to me, if the author had addressed the positive sides of the Modi era as well. Without it, the book seems more of a biased critique of the Modi govt, than a fair judgement, even though his criticisms were to the point and justified.

Modi is a made-for-TV politician—he is a terrific orator, has a narcisstic love for the camera and an uncanny knack to know what will make ‘news’

I would recommend the book to those who are interested in politics and like reading opinion pieces but might want to avoid it if you are looking for a completely unbiased read. Having said that, it is still a worthwhile read as it raises some relevant questions pertaining to the race to the big battle of 2019.

PS: I received a copy of the book from the publishers in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.


4 thoughts on “Book Review-Newsman: Tracking India in The Modi Era

  1. Aneesh says:

    To isolate the rise of Modi in India and analyzing it without taking stock of the general trend worldwide (THE RISE OF RIGHT WING Demagogues) is quiet surprising.
    I can learn from your review that the book focuses more on the assault on India’s Constitutional Ethos such as Secularism, Pluralism, Tolerance etc than on the Economic/Neo Liberal Policies or Governance aspects! From that perspective he is spot on!
    And when you weigh the Modi government after four years, the negatives far outweigh the positives no matter how hard you try.
    Neither Narendra Modi nor Indira Gandhi is the greatest Prime Minister of India. It still is Jawahar Lal Nehru!
    Thanks For The Review!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Reethu Ravi says:

      I agree with your point that his analysis is not based on the global trend of the rise of the right wing. This could also be because the book is a compilation of his previously written articles and not a current analysis. And for the same reason, I disagree with your point that a post-4-year analysis is bound to turn up more negative results. Because, the book contains articles that have been written all through Modi’s reign, right from 2014.
      Also, I don’t think he says either Indira Gandhi or Modi is the greatest prime minister of all time, he is moreover talking about how their strategies (like for instance Modi’s whole social media campaign) have been rather unconventional/different and left a huge impact (positive/negative) on the masses. And as for my point of view, I don’t think I am in a position to talk about who the greatest of ’em all is.
      Thank you for reading Aneesh! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s